Skip to tool
ecech.
🛒 E-commerce & Pricing

A Full Subscription Box Can Still Lose Money When Churn and Shipping Meet

Model contribution per shipment, monthly operating profit, payback time and churn-adjusted customer value in one view.

Monthly operating profit

Contribution / box

Contribution margin

Value after CAC

CAC payback

Advertisement

How the calculation works

Price per box$45.00Contribution$17.04At 8% churn12.5 monthsRecurring revenue matters only when each shipment contributes enough to recover acquisition cost.

How to Use This Tool

Subscription revenue can look predictable while cash disappears into products, packing, postage, replacements and payment fees every month. Contribution per box removes those variable costs from the subscription price. Multiply that amount by active shipments, then subtract fixed overhead to estimate monthly operating profit.

Churn changes what CAC is affordable

At a constant eight percent monthly churn, the simple expected lifetime is about 12.5 months. Multiplying monthly contribution by that lifetime gives a planning value before acquisition cost. This is a simplified steady-state model, not a cohort forecast: annual plans, pauses, win-backs and churn changing with tenure need cohort data.

Month 0− CACMonths 1–3contribution repays CACLater months create value only while the subscriber remains active.
Payback time shows how long cash is exposed before a customer becomes contribution-positive.

Use contribution, not gross margin, for decisions

Gross margin often ignores fulfilment, processor and replacement costs that rise with each shipment. Contribution includes them. Compare CAC payback with cash reserves and churn: a positive lifetime estimate can still be dangerous when the business runs out of cash before payback.

Sources & assumptions

Tool Spec v2 · verified 2026-08-18. Platform rules and fees can change; the editable inputs remain authoritative for your account.

Official references

Model assumptions

  • Monthly churn is treated as a constant probability, making expected customer lifetime approximately one divided by churn.
  • Contribution excludes fixed monthly overhead; operating profit subtracts that overhead after multiplying by active boxes.
Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is contribution per subscription box?
It is subscription price minus the variable costs caused by shipping one box: products, packaging, fulfilment, shipping, payment and expected refunds or replacements.
How does the calculator estimate customer lifetime?
It uses the simple steady-state approximation of one divided by monthly churn. At eight percent monthly churn, that is 12.5 months.
Is contribution the same as profit?
No. Contribution is before fixed overhead. Monthly operating profit subtracts the entered overhead after contribution is multiplied by active boxes.
What is value after CAC?
It is estimated lifetime contribution minus customer acquisition cost. It is a planning metric, not recognized accounting revenue.
Why can a positive LTV still be risky?
Acquisition is paid before months of contribution arrive. Slow payback, churn uncertainty and inventory purchases can create a cash shortage despite positive modeled value.
Should annual subscriptions use monthly churn?
Not directly. Convert retention using cohort data and model billing timing separately. The simple monthly model best fits recurring monthly shipments.

Related tools in E-commerce & Pricing

Browse all E-commerce & Pricing tools
The desk where ecech. tools get written: a laptop, a notebook of to-dos and a whiteboard listing the tools on the site.

Made by one person

ecech. is not a content farm. Every tool here is written and checked by hand, one at a time, by someone who wanted the tool to exist and could not find a version that showed its working.

No accounts and no sign-in, and nothing you type reaches a server — every calculation on this page runs inside your browser. The ads are served by Google and do set their own cookies, which is set out in full on the privacy page. More about the site.