Skip to tool
ecech.
💰 Financial & Currency

The Same First Payment: Eighty Years, or Eleven

The minimum is a percentage of a shrinking balance, so it shrinks too. Freezing it at today's figure changes almost everything.

This is arithmetic, not financial advice. Card terms vary, promotional rates expire, and any new spending restarts the calculation.

First month's minimum

 

Paying the minimum

 

Paying that same amount, fixed

 

Interest saved

by not letting it shrink

Why the minimum keeps falling

What a little more does

Advertisement

How the calculation works

$5,000 at 22%. Both start with a $100 payment. Fixed $100 137 months — $8,678 interest The minimum 968 months — 80.7 years — $43,419 interest Bars are 0.5 px per month. The only difference is that one payment stops shrinking. Same money in month one. $34,741 apart by the end.

How to Use This Tool

Enter the balance, the rate and the minimum formula from your statement. The two middle cards are the same first payment treated two different ways.

The minimum is a percentage of a moving target

A typical minimum is the greater of a flat floor, often $25, and a percentage of the current balance, often 2 per cent. Because it is recalculated against the balance every month, it falls as the balance falls.

That is the trap. You are always paying 2 per cent of a shrinking number, so the balance decays towards zero without arriving, and the interest keeps accruing on what is left. The floor eventually takes over and finishes the job, which is why the answer is finite rather than infinite — but only after decades.

$5,000 at 22% APR, minimum = max($25, 2% of balance)

first month's minimum                     $100.00

paying the minimum each month
   968 months = 80.7 years   interest  $43,419

paying a fixed $100 each month
   137 months = 11.4 years   interest   $8,678

difference   831 months and $34,741
The first payment is identical in both columns

Freezing the payment is the whole fix

The common advice is "pay more than the minimum", which sounds like it requires money you do not have. The stronger and cheaper version is pay the same amount every month — specifically, whatever this month's minimum is — and never let it decline.

That costs nothing extra in month one and almost nothing in month two. By month sixty the required minimum has fallen a long way and you are simply still paying what you were already paying, which is where the entire saving comes from.

Why the arithmetic feels wrong

At 22 per cent, monthly interest on $5,000 is about $91.67. A $100 minimum therefore reduces the balance by roughly $8 in the first month. Almost the whole payment is interest, and it stays that way for years, which is why progress feels invisible even when you never miss a payment.

The parts this model leaves out

Real cards vary: some compute the minimum as 1 per cent of the balance plus that month's interest and fees, which behaves differently. Promotional rates expire and jump. Fees are added to the balance. And any new spending on the card restarts everything, which is the single fastest way to make a payoff plan meaningless.

If the numbers here look impossible

An interest charge that exceeds what you can pay each month is a situation arithmetic cannot solve, and it is more common than people admit. Non-profit credit counselling services exist in most countries and are free or low cost; a balance transfer or a consolidation loan can also change the rate the maths runs at. This page can tell you what the numbers do, but not what you should do about them.

Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does paying the minimum take so long?
Because the minimum is a percentage of the current balance, so it falls as the balance falls. You are always paying 2 per cent of a shrinking number, which means the balance decays towards zero rather than reaching it.
How long to pay off $5,000 at 22 per cent?
Paying the declining minimum, about 968 months — 80.7 years — with $43,419 of interest. Paying a fixed $100, which is the same first payment, it is 137 months and $8,678.
What is the difference between paying the minimum and a fixed amount?
In month one, nothing. The minimum then falls each month while the fixed payment does not, and on a $5,000 balance at 22 per cent that difference alone is 831 months and $34,741 of interest.
How is a credit card minimum payment calculated?
Most commonly the greater of a flat floor, often $25, and a percentage of the balance, often 2 per cent. Some issuers use 1 per cent plus that month's interest and fees, which behaves somewhat differently but has the same declining shape.
Why does my balance barely move?
At 22 per cent, a $5,000 balance accrues about $91.67 of interest a month. A $100 payment therefore reduces the principal by around $8. Nearly all of an early payment is interest, which is why progress is invisible for years.
Does new spending affect this?
Completely. Any new purchase is added to the balance the calculation runs against, which raises the interest and resets the timeline. A payoff plan and continued use of the same card work against each other.

Related tools in Financial & Currency

Browse all Financial & Currency tools
The person who builds ecech., at the desk where the tools are written.

Made by one person

ecech. is not a content farm. Every tool here is written and checked by hand, one at a time, by someone who wanted the tool to exist and could not find a version that showed its working.

No accounts and no sign-in, and nothing you type reaches a server — every calculation on this page runs inside your browser. The ads are served by Google and do set their own cookies, which is set out in full on the privacy page. More about the site.